Brand new Bible says that in case a person wants an attentive, he may need this lady home and you will she stays in his family to have 1 month; when you find yourself here she need to would specific rituals. After that it says most specifically: „And after that you get means the woman and also intercourse with her and you can she will be your wife.” It would appear regarding an easy learning of your own biblical text one to zero sex are permitted up to after every one of the rituals enjoys started performed. Yerushalmi Makkot 2: 6 will follow which studying, Rabbi Yohanan reiterating around you to definitely zero sex are let up until all the the required rituals have been achieved.
Since discussed above, the new biblical consent getting an Israelite for taking an attentive woman is actually regarded as simply due to the fact an accommodation towards the evil choice out-of lust.
Midrash Tannaim and you will Midrash Hagadol partly target this dilemma and permit gender from the a level sooner than Sifrei and also the Yerushalmi. They state that when he has sex together prior to all the the latest recommended rituals was used, it is licentious. However, in the event that she willingly wants to transfer, she actually is ritually engrossed that’s permitted to him quickly. That it up coming satisfies their crave, relatively this new biblical intent according to sages, as well as have their court duty to help you wed just a beneficial Jewess. This type of supplies keeps moved brand new timing from sex send influenced by the newest transformation of your attentive, for example appear to interpret the 
law differently versus Yerushalmi.
Bavli Kiddushin 21b details a great amount of situations linked to intercourse with a captive in its talk towards the whether or not captive women can be allowed to priests. The point that this question is questioned verifies that it’s just gender, however relationships, that is getting talked about; in the place of other Israelites, priests commonly allowed to get married transforms. The issue is resolved you to because the Torah lets attentive females while the a good concession on the worst desires, we.age. crave, one act out of intercourse is unquestionably enabled. Just like the priests likewise have evil tendencies, they too are allowed one-act out of gender. But not, as good priest is not permitted to wed the latest attentive, a second work out-of sex isn’t permitted. Clearly, one act away from intercourse ‘s the sheer minimal in which the latest sages can fulfill what they imagine are biblical legislation. It can be translated that Bavli is setting restrictions towards access if you are looking to not to ever contravene the fresh new biblical law once the Bavli’s sages knew they.
This will be challenging: in the event the captor need certainly to waiting at the very least 1 month and you may follow a good proscribed ritual prior to they can have sex together, since Bible generally seems to suggest, just how can this meet the requirements a places in order to lust?
Obviously, the Yerushalmi, Bavli, and you can Midrashei Halakhah failed to see the legislation in the same method. The fresh Yerushalmi allows intercourse simply shortly after a 30 days, immediately after which transformation. The two Midrashei Halakhah succeed intercourse merely shortly after transformation. The fresh Bavli lets sex, however, only once, till the captor must take on duty.
The guy explains the Babylonian sages, exactly who teach-in title off Rab that the basic intimate gender was allowed prior to that point, are completely wrong
This new Bavli continues to declare that an attentive woman need to be studied only for the fresh new warrior themselves and never for somebody more, and then he must not oppress her (yelahatsenah) towards battlefield. The brand new sages obtain that it practise throughout the particular sequence recorded into the Deut. 21: eleven,12: you desire the girl, and you must get the lady because the a spouse, then you definitely should bring their to your home, but you shouldn’t oppress the woman for the battleground (bKiddushin 22a).